Grad shape
Grad shape
Case Study

Lloyds Banking Group

Digital Transformation Project

Commercial Lending Journey - Multi-signatory contract signing & tracking

2017—2018

At a glance

About the company

Lloyds Banking Group is a leading UK-based financial services group. They provide a wide range of banking and financial services, focused primarily on retail and serves approximately one million commercial banking customers in the UK. They provide banking services for businesses of all sizes, from start-ups to established enterprises.
https://www.lloydsbankinggroup.com/

At a glance

Project Overview

Role

Lead Senior Product / UX Designer

Team

1x Senior User Researcher
1x Senior Visual Designer
1x Business Analyst
Team of Developers
QA Engineers

Year

2017 — 2018

Duration

9—12 months

Tools

Axure RP
Adobe Photoshop
Adobe Illustrator

Project

Key Activities

Service Design
Business Process Re-engineering
User Research
User Interviews
Cognitive Walkthrough
Heuristic Evaluation
Task Analysis
Information Architecture & Design
Responsive Web Design
Interaction Design
User-Interface Design
Visual Design
Data Visualisation
Prototyping
Usability Testing
Project

Key Outcomes

Lowered annual operating costs by £ millions

Reduction in call-centre demand by designing a brand new digital-only frictionless and seamless self-serve user journey

Faster customer service fulfillment (94% faster)

Reduced time it takes for customers to receive their cash ("time-to-cash") from an average of 16 days down to 1 day (94% reduction).

Highest usability ratings (98%)

Multiple rounds of public user-testing resulted in a overall usability and user satisfaction scores of 4.9/5 (on the first design iteration)

Design expanded to other use-cases

Due to its success, the workflow and UI were adapted for multi-document signing and tracking in property transactions — supporting multiple signatories (e.g. solicitors, surveyors, buyers, sellers) and adding features for document editing and markup.

Final Product

Journey Map & Mockups

Although the service eventually went live, I am not in possession of any final designs or screenshots. The mockups illustrated are 95% accurate to the final version that was developed.

View Larger PDF version

Project Overview

Objective

Design an end-to-end digital self-service journey for SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises) to apply for credit cards, unsecured loans, and overdrafts — with minimal colleague intervention to reduce operational costs associated with call centres.

Key Goals

  • Enable businesses to apply for single or multiple products via a digital-only experience.
  • Support complex company structures, including multiple directors and legal signatories.
  • Provide functionality for document signing and tracking, reducing dependency on traditional mail workflows.

Business Requirements

  • Businesses must be able to apply for unsecured loans, secured loans, and credit cards.
  • Applications for a single product (e.g. a business loan) can be completed entirely online via the Product Selection Tool, providing a streamlined, digital experience.
  • Multi-product applications (e.g. loan + credit card + overdraft) currently follow a traditional telephony process, but applicants can still:

    • Track progress
    • Complete document signing
    • Access updates

    via the new digital interface.

  • Applications typically require multiple documents to be signed.
  • Companies may have multiple authorised signatories (e.g. two directors and a secretary), all of whom must sign the same set of documents.
  • Historically, this caused delays — particularly when signatories had different addresses — as documents had to be physically mailed and signed sequentially, often resulting in long wait times.

Design Considerations

  • Although the original brief focused on a desktop web experience, the project scope later expanded to include mobile web.

    • I had originally designed the solution with responsive behaviours and content stacking in mind, so content structure remained unchanged for the mobile web requirement.
    • I did have to retrospectively update the mockups to visually demonstrate how the responsive design would function across viewports.
  • Given the complexity of multi-product applications and multi-signatory workflows, a key challenge was designing modular, reusable UI components.

    • These needed to adapt to various scenarios while maintaining a clear information hierarchy and visual clarity.
    • The interface had to support permutations such as different combinations of products, varying user roles, and asynchronous document signing — all in a consistent and user-friendly way.
Process

Task analysis and journey mapping

To understand the current process for business customers to apply for lending products either in-branch or via a telephony journey, identify pain-points and opportunities to improve workflow and remediate those pain-points.

Lo-fi wire-flows

Pen and paper low-fidelity wire-flows were drawn up and reiterated on before being shared with stakeholders for validation from a business perspective. Once these were approved, it was time to turn these lo-fi design artefacts into hi-fidelity versions.

Hi-fidelity mockups

Static hi-fi mockups were built in Axure, to illustrate screen layout, information hierarchy, and content.

Whilst the project brief was initially to build a desktop browser experience, half-way through the project, there was a revised requirement to also design and build for a mobile experience. These mockups had to be adjusted to illustrate mobile screen sizes.

Interactive prototype

The hi-fidelity mockups of each screen were linked-up within Axure and added interactive behaviours to create a fully interactive clickable prototype to be used for user-testing.

Animation is integral to the user experience and I wanted users to see the gradual loading of content through the fade-in animations and transitions between page or content states. This was 'baked' into the Axure prototype for user testing and as a reference for developers to implement.

User testing

Preparation

I prepared an interview script based on the types of questions I wanted answered.

The Senior User Researcher refined it further and added their own questions.

Recruitment

Recruited numerous business owners (an even mix of existing Lloyds and non-Lloyds customers) for multiple user-testing sessions to be held within the Lloyds Banking Group dedicated on-site usability lab, over the span of a few months during the design process.

Participant size limited to six people per session, mainly due to difficulty in recruiting willing participants (to come to the Lloyds usability lab in London).

Participants were also selected to represent a wide demographic (age group, time in business, tech-savvy or tech-illiterate, business turnover, industry type).

For example:

  • a university graduate, early 20s, recently started their own e-commerce business, IT-literate, annual-turnover: £ tens of thousands
  • a millionaire businessman, in their late 40s-early 50s, in property and building trade
  • a self-employed housewife, mid 30s, non tech-savvy, running a small mail-order business from home
  • a tradesman, self-employed, early 40s, not that tech-savvy, turnover £100k
  • A company director. in their 50s, in a company with three other signatories, had bad experience applying for a business loan with another bank

Format

Each participant was asked to step-through each stage within the interactive (clickable) Axure prototype, providing commentary on their thoughts and planned actions.

The Usability Lab was equipped with eye-tracking hardware and software but it was not used for these occasions.

User-Testing Feedback

Common reactions from participants

from the very first design iteration of the working prototype.

"This is so easy to use and understand."
"I wish my bank [ Barclays ] offered this!"
"Makes applying for a loan or credit card so straight-forward!"
"Love the contract multi-signing and tracking feature!"
Usability Test Scores

Average 'ease-of-use' score

(on a scale between 1 and 5) from user-testing of the initial version of the proposed workflow solution:

4.9 out of 5

Rating:

1 - Most Difficult

Easiest - 5

(Higher score is better)

Average user-satisfaction score

(on a scale between 1 and 5) from user-testing of the initial version of the proposed workflow solution:

4.9 out of 5

Rating:

1 - Most Unsatisfied

Most Satisfied - 5

(Higher score is better)

The Build

The Biggest Challenge

Third-Party Document Signing: A Potential Trust Issue

In addition to the usual development challenges — such as integrating legacy systems like the risk and credit scoring engine — it became apparent late in the project that the PDF signing functionality would not be handled in-house. Instead, it would be outsourced to Adobe EchoSign (now Adobe Sign), a third-party service that operated under its own domain name and branding.

This was the first time I had been made aware of this decision. I immediately flagged it as a significant usability and trust risk: users would be redirected away from the familiar Lloyds interface to a completely different domain (with no Lloyds branding), which could easily be mistaken for a phishing attempt — especially considering the sensitive nature of the documents being signed.

My Mitigation Strategy

Since there was no technical solution to embed the PDF signing step directly within the Lloyds online banking experience, I proposed a two-part mitigation plan:

  • Clear User Communication

    All signatories would receive an email explaining that the document signing would take place via a trusted third-party provider (Adobe EchoSign), and that the different domain was expected and safe.

  • Branding the EchoSign Environment

    Although customisation options were limited, I worked with the team to incorporate a Lloyds-branded header and logo within the EchoSign interface to provide reassurance and maintain visual continuity.

These solutions were well received by stakeholders and successfully implemented as part of the final experience.

Update: Since this project, Adobe has retired the EchoSign brand and now operates under Adobe Sign. Source

Summary

Conclusion

Project Impact & Outcomes

Frictionless End-to-end Workflow for 1M Business Customers

I'm incredibly proud of the results delivered through this large-scale, high-impact project. By thoroughly analysing business objectives, identifying pain points in the existing user journey, and working within the constraints of legacy backend systems, I was able to design a frictionless end-to-end workflow for Lloyds Banking Group's one million commercial customers.

Accelerated Lending: From Weeks to Days

This new journey reduced the "time-to-cash" period from 16 days down to just 1-2 days (a reduction of 94%), while accommodating every known edge case.

User-Centred Design That Got It Right First Time

In the very first design iteration, the solution achieved an average user satisfaction and ease-of-use score of 4.9 / 5 in usability testing. Subsequent iterations focused only on minor visual refinements.

Mobile-Ready Before It Was Required

Although mobile web wasn't part of the original brief, I had already designed with responsiveness in mind — ensuring the experience would seamlessly adapt to smaller screens. So when mobile support was added mid-project, users were able to apply for loans just as easily on mobile as on desktop, with no additional design effort required.

Reduced Operating Costs for the Business

The new digital self-serve journey significantly reduced call-centre demand, allowing staffing and infrastructure to be scaled back — resulting in annual cost savings of several million pounds.

Going Beyond the Brief

Although not part of the original scope, I identified a gap in the customer experience: a lack of accessible, product-specific documentation in the lending servicing interface. I proactively proposed:

  • A dedicated document hub for users to view and download all signed agreements and related legal documents.
  • A redesigned payment history view featuring a progress bar to help users visualise how much of their balance had been repaid.
  • Introduce clearer pathways to allow customers to repay back their loans early or extend their loan period without them having to call Customer Services.

These enhancements were extremely well received by both stakeholders and users during testing, and were included in the final design.

You can view this proposal on the PDF version of the Journey Map diagram - Item 13 - "Lending Product Servicing Page".

Multi-Signatory Expansion

The success of the multi-signatory contract signing workflow led to a proposal to extend the approach to commercial property purchases — involving multiple signatories such as conveyancers, surveyors, and company directors.

This extended journey included support for in-document markup and revision requests from each party. The concept was again well received by stakeholders, though it was eventually “parked” for future development due to shifting priorities.

A Small Selection

Testimonials

If you need a professional and reliable UX designer with great and broad set of skills, great technical background, experience and ability to resolve the most complex design problems, look no further.

Yooch is also genuine, honest and fun to work with.

I hired him for two companies already and I'll do it without the shadow of hesitation if the chance comes again.

— Jiri S. Human-Centred Design Lead - Commercial Lending Value Stream.

Jiri managed Yooch directly at Lloyds Banking Group and worked together at Thomson Reuters

I worked with Yooch for over 9 months on various projects.

I validated his design concepts on some key projects within the bank. They were well received by internal and external users.

His designs are very well thought through and intuitive.

He is very professional, easy to work with and an expert in his field. I wish him the best of luck in all his future endeavours.

— Rupal S. Senior User Researcher

Rupal worked with Yooch in the same group at Lloyds Banking Group

Yooch is an all round solid designer, I can't recommend him highly enough. With all my honesty, he's a true gold mine of creative solutions and fresh ideas. He will go the extra mile and surprise you with something innovative and unique.

Apart from being an outstanding UX generalist, Yooch has solid front-end engineering skills too and is comfortable with taking his design ideas further by building proper, fully interactive prototypes. It was refreshing to meet another UXer who's fluent in JavaScript, HTML and CSS.

He's a rare find, a creative thinker with a remarkable combination of skills. Equally importantly, Yooch is an interesting person with a wide range of interests, he's just fun to be around! I genuinely believe Yooch would be a perfect addition to any creative team, I'd never hesitate to recommend him.

— UX Consultant, Creative Technologist @ Lloyds Banking Group

Balazs worked with Yooch in the same group at Lloyds Banking Group and London Stock Exchange Group / Refinitiv

More testimonials

You can find 4 more testimonials from colleagues at Lloyds Banking Group in the testimonials section.

Verify these testimonials

View them on Linkedin Recommendations